top of page

Employment Contract or Service Agreement? The difference that can change all your rights.

4 days ago
7 min read

In Portugal, many people work for years convinced that they are independent service providers. They issue green receipts, receive a monthly sum, and have no written employment contract. However, the reality of the professional relationship may reveal a very different legal situation.

The issue is particularly important because the designation given to the contract does not, in itself, determine its true nature.

A contract called a "service agreement" can, legally, be considered an employment contract.

And this difference can have profound consequences for the worker and for the entity that benefits from their activity.

1. What distinguishes an employment contract from a service contract?

The fundamental distinction lies in the existence, or not, of legal subordination .

According to Article 11 of the Labor Code, an employment contract is characterized by the provision of paid work within an organization and under the authority of another person or entity.

In turn, Article 1154 of the Civil Code defines a service contract as one in which one party undertakes to provide the other with a specific result of their intellectual or manual work, with or without remuneration.

In the provision of truly independent services, the professional retains autonomy in the organization and execution of their activity, within the limits of the obligations contractually assumed.

In an employment contract, the activity is carried out within the organization and under the authority of the employer.

This difference is crucial.

2. What is legal subordination?

Legal subordination translates to the worker being subject to the employer's power of direction, under the terms applicable by law.

It can manifest itself through orders, instructions, control of activity, integration into the business structure, and the exercise of disciplinary powers.

It is not necessary for the employer to constantly give orders.

In certain professions, especially in technical and intellectual activities, the worker may benefit from a high degree of autonomy in performing their duties while remaining legally subordinate.

Therefore, the analysis should not be limited to the existence of daily instructions.

What matters is verifying the actual structure of the professional relationship.

3. What does Article 12 of the Labor Code say?

Article 12 establishes a legal presumption of the existence of an employment contract when certain characteristics described therein are met.

These characteristics include:

Workplace

The activity is carried out in facilities belonging to the beneficiary or in a location designated by them.

Work equipment

The instruments and equipment used belong to the beneficiary of the activity.

Time

The professional observes the start and end times of the service as determined by the beneficiary.

Periodic remuneration

A fixed amount is paid at regular intervals as compensation for the activity.

Integration into the business structure

The professional performs management or leadership functions within the company organization.

Verification of at least two of the legally stipulated characteristics may allow the presumption of employment to be triggered, without prejudice to legal assessment and the possibility of the presumption being rebutted.

It is not necessary for all the evidence stipulated by law to be present.

It should also not be concluded that the isolated existence of one of these elements automatically determines whether the relationship qualifies as an employment contract.

The presumption of employment is a fundamental instrument for worker protection. If at least two of the circumstances foreseen in Article 12, No. 1, of the Labor Code are demonstrated, the existence of an employment contract is presumed. This means that the worker does not have to independently demonstrate all the elements characterizing legal subordination: it is up to the entity benefiting from the activity to present evidence capable of rebutting this presumption. The assessment must consider the reality of the relationship and not only the document signed by the parties.

4. A practical example: service provision or employment contract?

Imagine the following situation.

A company hires a professional through a document called a "Service Agreement".

The professional issues a green receipt monthly.

However:

  • Works daily at the company's facilities;

  • Follows a schedule determined by the company;

  • Uses the equipment provided by the company;

  • Receives a fixed amount monthly;

  • She is part of a team and receives instructions from a supervisor.

  • You need to coordinate your absences with the company organization.

Despite the contractual designation, these elements may reveal a genuine subordinate employment relationship.

Qualification requires a comprehensive analysis of the situation, but issuing green receipts does not preclude the application of labor legislation.

5. What if the worker voluntarily signed the service agreement?

Signing a document does not prevent the relationship from being legally classified as an employment contract.

The same applies when the professional has agreed to issue green receipts or has registered their business activity with the tax authorities.

The will declared by the parties is a relevant element, but it does not automatically prevail over the reality of the work performed and over mandatory labor regulations.

Simply writing "independent service provider" on a contract is not enough to avoid the application of the Labor Code.

This is one of the most important issues that workers and companies need to understand.

6. Does working exclusively for one company mean having an employment contract?

Not necessarily.

An independent professional can provide services to a single client without this, in itself, implying the existence of an employment contract.

Economic dependence and legal subordination are different concepts.

The Labor Code also addresses certain situations of economically dependent self-employed workers, with a specific protection regime.

The decisive element for job qualification continues to be the verification of the legal requirements of the employment contract.

Therefore, exclusivity should be considered in conjunction with the other elements of the professional relationship.

7. What rights might be at stake?

When a relationship presented as a service agreement actually corresponds to an employment contract, there may be labor rights at stake that were not recognized during its execution.

Depending on the circumstances, questions may arise regarding:

  • Vacation and corresponding compensation;

  • Vacation allowance;

  • Christmas bonus;

  • Limits on working hours;

  • Overtime work;

  • Protection upon termination of the employment relationship;

  • Antique;

  • Occupational health and safety;

  • Contribution framework with regard to Social Security.

The recognition of the existence of an employment contract does not mean that all these credits are automatically due in the same amount.

It is necessary to analyze the specific relationship, the payments made, the relevant periods, and the applicable legal deadlines.

8. What happens when the company ends the relationship?

Often, the true nature of the contractual relationship is only questioned when the company informs the professional that it no longer needs their services.

If a genuine provision of services exists, the termination should be assessed according to the applicable contractual and civil law regime.

However, if the relationship legally corresponds to an employment contract, termination may be subject to labor laws.

In this case, the notification that the services are no longer needed may raise questions regarding the existence of a dismissal and its legality.

The consequences depend on the specific facts, the method of termination, and the applicable legal requirements.

The company cannot disregard the rules of dismissal simply because it has decided to call the contractual relationship a service provision agreement.

9. Is it necessary to go to court to have an employment contract recognized?

It is not always necessary to initiate legal action immediately.

There are legal mechanisms in place to combat the misuse of service contracts.

The Authority for Working Conditions (ACT) can intervene when there are indications of a situation of apparently autonomous work under conditions characteristic of an employment contract.

Article 15-A of Law No. 107/2009, of September 14, provides for a procedure aimed at regularizing these situations.

When the legal requirements are met, the intervention of the ACT (Authority for Working Conditions) may lead to the regularization of the situation or to the communication of the facts to the Public Prosecutor's Office, for the purpose of initiating the special action for recognition of the existence of an employment contract.

This action is regulated in articles 186-K et seq. of the Labor Procedure Code.

The worker may also need to resort to appropriate legal means to enforce specific rights arising from the employment relationship.

10. What evidence might be important?

When there is a disagreement about the nature of the contractual relationship, proof of how the work was actually performed takes on particular importance.

They may prove relevant:

  • Contracts and addendums;

  • Email messages;

  • Instructions given by superiors;

  • Time records;

  • Communications regarding vacations and absences;

  • Receipts and proof of payments;

  • Documents relating to the use of equipment;

  • Organizational charts and internal communications;

  • Witness testimonies.

The relevance of each element depends on the facts to be demonstrated and the applicable procedural rules.

The collection and preservation of documentation must comply with the law, including rules on confidentiality and data protection.

11. What are the risks for companies?

The misuse of service contracts can lead to significant liabilities.

Article 12, paragraph 2, of the Labor Code provides for a very serious offense when there is the provision of apparently autonomous activity under conditions characteristic of an employment contract, likely to cause harm to the worker or the State.

Further consequences may arise related to the recognition of the employment relationship, employee credits, contribution obligations, and termination of the relationship.

The risk doesn't disappear just because both parties signed a service agreement.

Therefore, before hiring an independent professional, the company should verify whether the actual organization of the activity is compatible with the autonomy inherent in this type of contract.

12. Why is it important to analyze the relationship before a conflict arises?

For the worker, legal analysis allows them to understand whether the professional relationship actually corresponds to a service provision or whether there are elements that justify the recognition of an employment contract.

For the company, it allows for the identification of qualification risks and the correction of contractually inadequate situations.

In both cases, preventive intervention can avoid prolonged conflicts and significant costs.

The true nature of a professional relationship should be analyzed from the outset—not just when one of the parties decides to end it.

Employment contract or service agreement? Request a legal analysis.

Does he work on a freelance basis, but adhere to set hours, receive instructions, and is integrated into a company's organization?

Are you a business owner looking to hire service providers without risking the creation of a disguised employment relationship?

Magda Ferreirinha — Lawyer provides legal services including the analysis and qualification of contractual relationships, drafting and reviewing employment and service contracts, as well as advising on situations involving the potential misuse of independent work.

Legal intervention allows for the assessment of specific circumstances, the identification of applicable rights and obligations, and the definition of appropriate means to protect legally safeguarded interests.

Request a legal assessment of your contractual situation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not replace individualized legal advice.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page